Wherebly Wherebly.
  • Home
  • Cities
  • Stories
  • How It Works
  • For Restaurants
  • About
Help Share a place
Home › United States › New York › Third Rail Coffee › Menu

Third Rail Coffee menu.

Discover Third Rail Coffee’s expertly crafted espresso, cold brew, lattes, teas, and pastries in a cozy NYC espresso bar. Enjoy friendly service and rich flavors in Greenwich Village.

— Week of 23 Mar, 2026 —
Items 10
about this week's card —

About the menu

Introducing the Menu at Third Rail Coffee

Located in the heart of New York City at 240 Sullivan Street, Third Rail Coffee offers a carefully curated menu that celebrates the art of espresso and classic coffee brewing. Their selection ranges from a bold Espresso ($3.75) to smooth Americanos, creamy Lattes, and rich Mocha ($5.75). For those seeking a refreshing alternative, the Cold Brew and simple Drip coffee ($2.75) stand out with well-balanced flavors. Tea enthusiasts will find both hot and iced options, including Chai ($4.50) and herbal brews, along with comforting Hot Chocolate ($4.00).

Beyond beverages, Third Rail’s pastries—especially the muffins—draw loyal fans, offering a delightful complement to the expertly brewed coffee. The spot’s charm also lies in its casual, inviting vibe, where friendly baristas and a well-curated soundtrack create a welcoming experience. Whether stopping by for a quick espresso or savoring a leisurely cup with a snack, Third Rail Coffee shines as an essential stop for coffee lovers in the city.

Allergies or dietary restrictions? Please ask staff before ordering — they can talk you through every dish. Menus change often, so symbols aren't always up to date.
from the pass —

Menu photos

A few dishes from the current card — tap any shot to view larger.

Menu Photo 1
Menu Photo 2
1 / 2

Items

10 items

Espresso

$3.75

Americano

Latte

Mocha

$5.75

Cold Brew

Drip

$2.75

Tea

$3.75

Iced Tea

$4.00

Hot Choc

$4.00

Chai

$4.50
from a recent review —
Easily my favorite coffee shop in the city. From the espresso, to the drip and cold brew, the Third Rail crew knows coffee and how to make folks feel at home. The pastries are incredible, if you can get in early enough to grab one, and the music is always on point.
Kahaari Kenyatta
Mar 11, 2026
ready to visit —

Plan your visit.

Opening hours, the full address and the best way to get there are all on the restaurant page. Booking policies differ from place to place — so call ahead, or simply walk in.

View overview Call +1 646-580-9416
WhereblyWherebly.

A friendly guide to neighbourhood restaurants — written by the people who actually eat there.

Explore
  • Cities
  • Stories
  • Homepage
  • Submit a place
Community
  • How it works
  • Manifesto
  • Contact
For places
  • For restaurants
  • Brand page
Company
  • About
  • Help
  • Privacy
  • Terms
© Wherebly · Hand-edited in 17 cities · Never advertised
Made for people who eat more than they post.