Coffee shops

Third Rail Coffee

A 22-seat kitchen run by Eleni & Yassine, serving the dishes their grandmothers argued about on Tuesday nights in Kreuzberg.

240 Sullivan St, New York, NY 10012, United States $1–10
4.2
381 notes from regulars
01 The story, in three paragraphs

Why everyone keeps coming back.

Located in the heart of New York’s vibrant Greenwich Village, Third Rail Coffee is much more than your typical coffee shop—it’s a beloved espresso bar that perfectly blends exceptional craft coffee with a welcoming neighborhood vibe. Whether you’re a devoted espresso lover or someone who enjoys savoring a meticulously brewed drip coffee or a refreshing cold brew, Third Rail delivers an experience that truly resonates with coffee aficionados and casual drinkers alike.

The menu is carefully curated to please a wide array of tastes without overwhelming the senses. Sip on a rich, velvety espresso for just $3.75 or indulge in a creamy mocha or latte priced around $5.75, each made with an expert hand that teases out layered flavors with every sip. For something lighter, the Americano and tea offerings provide smooth, comforting options that keep you coming back. The cold brew, praised frequently by patrons, is perfectly balanced, bold yet refreshingly clean, ideal for an energizing afternoon boost. Pair your coffee with one of their sought-after pastries—grab them early if you can, as they tend to fly off the shelves—creating a harmonious contrast of flavors and textures that makes each visit memorable.

What sets Third Rail Coffee apart is not just the drinks, but the atmosphere that wraps around every customer like a warm embrace. Loyal customers like Kahaari Kenyatta rave about the friendly, knowledgeable baristas who don’t just serve coffee but create a sense of home, turning a simple caffeine fix into an inviting ritual. The cozy interior, along with a small outdoor seating area, provides a perfect nook to savor your coffee and soak in the dynamic energy of Sullivan Street. This balance of intimacy and urban rhythm is a magnet for those seeking moments of calm in the city’s buzz.

While some visitors note that the venue’s exterior and service could use some polish, many give glowing praise to the staff’s warmth and efficiency once inside. The ambiance is further enhanced by a carefully selected music playlist that complements the mood without overpowering conversations or solitary reflection. Regulars like Jesse Soursourian and Asad Jahangir appreciate the consistent quality of both coffee and service—testimony to Third Rail’s commitment to its craft and community.

In essence, Third Rail Coffee is an authentic New York gem where excellent espresso meets genuine hospitality. It’s a destination for anyone who values not only a superior cup of coffee but also the sense of connection that comes with it. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, stepping into Third Rail is stepping into a space where coffee is celebrated and every sip tells a story.

03 Notes from regulars

381 notes — the real pulse of the room.

4.2
Based on 381 verified notes
5 226
4 84
3 35
2 18
1 26
All Muffins Small Coffee Shop Small Space Small Seats Cosy Spot Pastries Drip Coffee Mocha Baristas Bagels
Kahaari Kenyatta.
3 month ago
Easily my favorite coffee shop in the city. From the espresso, to the drip and cold brew, the Third Rail crew knows coffee and how to make folks feel at home. The pastries are incredible, if you can get in early enough to grab one, and the music is always on point.
Save Share
Ana Sofía Vázquez.
3 month ago
The coffee is good and this place has good prices in general. The only thing I didn’t get is the pumpkin-banana bread. The pumpkin bread itself is good and the banana thing is just not right. The venue is not so cool and it’s somewhat dirty outside. Also, the service could improve a lot.
Save Share
Jesse Soursourian.
4 month ago
Been coming here for years. Love the friendly baristas and delicious coffee and muffins!
Save Share
Asad Jahangir (Lion).
5 month ago
Awesome coffee, I absolutely loved the overall vibe. Was actually pleasantly surprised how you can get such a good coffee just around the corner. There were a couple of small benches and tables infrint of the shop where you can sit and enjoy your morning coffee.
Save Share
Regina Miller.
5 month ago
The coziest of places with fast & friendly service! Plenty of menu options for its size. The hibiscus berry lemonade was terrific.
Save Share
Nathalie Baker.
6 month ago
Fun place to relax and have a snack. Friendly staff. Great drinks. Nice muffins
Save Share
Taylor Snipes.
6 month ago
One of the best places for a quick coffee in the NYU neighborhood. They don’t allow people inside since covid but still worth stopping by for a quick brew. My favorite is their cold brew and the iced latte. Add some oat milk in there if that’s your style.
Save Share
Steve N..
6 month ago
Found this small coffee shop while visiting nearby Washington Square Park. The solo worker managed the crowds like a champ, was friendly, and made a great espresso!
Save Share
04 When to visit & how to find us

Hours & the door on Bergmannstraße.

Opening hours
Monday (today) 08:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Tuesday 08:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Wednesday 08:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Thursday 08:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Friday 08:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Saturday 09:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Sunday 09:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Finding the door

240 Sullivan St, New York, NY 10012, United States

05 What makes this place friendly

The details you usually have to call and ask.

From the business
  • Identifies as Latino-owned
  • Small business
Service options
  • Outdoor seating
  • Onsite services
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
  • No Delivery
Highlights
  • Great coffee
  • Great tea selection
Popular for
  • Breakfast
Accessibility
  • No Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
  • Coffee
  • Organic dishes
  • Prepared foods
  • Quick bite
  • Vegan options
  • Vegetarian options
Dining options
  • Breakfast
  • Dessert
  • Seating
  • No Table service
Amenities
  • No Restroom
Atmosphere
  • Casual
  • Cozy
  • Trendy
Crowd
  • College students
  • LGBTQ+ friendly
Planning
  • No Accepts reservations
Payments
  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
Children
  • Good for kids
Saved this place? Add a note after your visit.

Notes from real diners are how the next person finds this table. 50–80 words is perfect.

Write my note